Here's Hayley singing Kate Bush's classic live, 2004. Enjoy all! (and judging from the bitterness contained within comments on the WH video clip, please respect each other's opnions!)
Totally agree! This girl is singing this like it's a happy love song when it is in fact about obsession. Vocally she is there but interpretation ....very off!
grahamjy - sounds as though you simply don't like Hayley Westenra! My suggestion - pee off and bore some other forum and maybe go find a life!
Well I for one for that was awesome!!!
grahamjy. The thing that keeps amazing me is why if this is such a bad version KB fanatics keep coming back and commenting on it. Do they see a threat? This is the second most watched version of WH on YT. There is an obvious reposte to your comment but I will resist the temptation.
She sings pretty good but is too happy, though....
I think "thetopofmylungs" means that Cathy is dead when she "sings" this song
who's dead?....watch the film wuthering heights...its about two people in love
she got really clean voice,I like it ,let not forget this song is really chalenge
i dont think its supposed to be joyful... shes dead
It's pathetic what you people say about this girl!I mean come on she's INCREDIBLE!OK so she's not Kate Bush(nothing ever beats the original,that's the way it is)but you can't say IDIOTIC things like ''she's horrible''(are you deaf)!
Amazing,it's good to see that there is a hope for today's music after all!
Her voice is good, but I don't think she get's the feeling of the song.
this version sucks, it's not supposed to feel joy, but the weight of feelings like
"how could you leave me when i wanted to possess you / i hated you i loved you too"
hate it.
clearly you lack taste if you this this is a good version
This is great! She's a good singer. I like her just as much as Kate Bush.
This is an incredibly hard song to sing correctly. I use it as my warm-up song before any event because I figure, if I can sing Wuthering Heights even slightly correctly, anything else I sing after that will be cake!
Love this version. The musical arrangement and her voice has a sense of joy and lightness that the version from Kate Bush is missing. Like Kate's original as well, but like this better.
Can I be 47 and play Guild Wars in that closet!
well I've been pretentioussly commenting on youtube videos as if I have authority for two years now, does that make me an expert?
rubberdu - thanks for those insightful, indepth comments. Now back to your closet!
she is such a good singer omg she takes my breath away xx
If you are a singer, please stay away from this song.
I have heard 20 covers of WH and this verision sucked the least.
But still it sucked.
the lady in wuthering heights was meant to be cold
i prefer he voice to kate bush kate's vice annoys me
コメント
Totally agree! This girl is singing this like it's a happy love song when it is in fact about obsession. Vocally she is there but interpretation ....very off!
grahamjy - sounds as though you simply don't like Hayley Westenra! My suggestion - pee off and bore some other forum and maybe go find a life!
Well I for one for that was awesome!!!
grahamjy. The thing that keeps amazing me is why if this is such a bad version KB fanatics keep coming back and commenting on it. Do they see a threat? This is the second most watched version of WH on YT. There is an obvious reposte to your comment but I will resist the temptation.
She sings pretty good but is too happy, though....
I think "thetopofmylungs" means that Cathy is dead when she "sings" this song
who's dead?....watch the film wuthering heights...its about two people in love
she got really clean voice,I like it ,let not forget this song is really chalenge
i dont think its supposed to be joyful... shes dead
It's pathetic what you people say about this girl!I mean come on she's INCREDIBLE!OK so she's not Kate Bush(nothing ever beats the original,that's the way it is)but you can't say IDIOTIC things like ''she's horrible''(are you deaf)! Amazing,it's good to see that there is a hope for today's music after all!
Her voice is good, but I don't think she get's the feeling of the song.
this version sucks, it's not supposed to feel joy, but the weight of feelings like "how could you leave me when i wanted to possess you / i hated you i loved you too" hate it.
clearly you lack taste if you this this is a good version
This is great! She's a good singer. I like her just as much as Kate Bush.
This is an incredibly hard song to sing correctly. I use it as my warm-up song before any event because I figure, if I can sing Wuthering Heights even slightly correctly, anything else I sing after that will be cake!
Love this version. The musical arrangement and her voice has a sense of joy and lightness that the version from Kate Bush is missing. Like Kate's original as well, but like this better.
Can I be 47 and play Guild Wars in that closet!
well I've been pretentioussly commenting on youtube videos as if I have authority for two years now, does that make me an expert?
rubberdu - thanks for those insightful, indepth comments. Now back to your closet!
she is such a good singer omg she takes my breath away xx
If you are a singer, please stay away from this song. I have heard 20 covers of WH and this verision sucked the least. But still it sucked.
the lady in wuthering heights was meant to be cold
i prefer he voice to kate bush kate's vice annoys me
Better than Kate Bush. Hayley is amazing
too cold